Doctor Who has been a significant part of television history for over six decades. Since its debut in 1963, the series has captivated audiences with its imaginative storytelling, iconic characters, and the central figure of the Doctor, a Time Lord from the planet Gallifrey who travels through time and space in the TARDIS. Over the years, the Doctor has been portrayed by a diverse array of actors, each bringing their unique flair to this iconic character, ensuring that the show remains fresh and engaging for each new generation of viewers.
This ranking will delve into each Doctor’s era, examining their key characteristics, memorable moments, and the impact they had on the series. From the groundbreaking early days of William Hartnell to the modern-day popularity of David Tennant and beyond, each Doctor has left an indelible mark on the series. Let’s explore what made each Doctor unique, how they contributed to the rich world of Doctor Who, and determine who stands out as the best Doctor Who in the show’s illustrious history.
Ncuti Gatwa – Too Early to Tell?
Now that Ncuti Gatwa is at the helm of the Doctor Who franchise, excitement and curiosity are at an all-time high. Known for his role in the hit Netflix series, Sex Education, Gatwa is bringing energy to the role. At just 31 years old, he is one of the youngest actors to play the Doctor, promising a dynamic and fresh take on the beloved character. While it’s too early to rank him among his predecessors, there’s palpable excitement about his potential to redefine the role.
Ranking the best Doctor Who
Ratings correct as of 04/06/2024
13 – Jodie Whittaker (2017-2022)
Number of episodes: 32
Average IMDB Rating: 6.5
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S12.E8 – “The Haunting of Villa Diodati” – IMDB Rating 8.2
- S12.E5 – “Fugitive of the Judoon” – IMDB Rating 8.1
- S11.E3 – “Rosa” – IMDB Rating 8.0
3 worst rated episodes:
- S12.E3 – “Orphan 55” – IMDB Rating 4.0
- S11.E10 – “The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos” – IMDB Rating 4.3
- S11.E5 – “The Tsuranga Conundrum” – IMDB Rating 4.5
Jodie Whittaker’s tenure as the Doctor marked a historic shift as she became the first woman to play the role. Despite this groundbreaking moment, her era was marked by uneven writing and fluctuating reception from fans. Whittaker brought an energetic, friendly, and protective demeanor to the Doctor, with a notable northern charm. Memorable moments include her heartfelt performance in “Rosa,” addressing historical racism, and her emotional showdown with the Master. However, some episodes were poorly received due to weak plots and character development.
12 – Colin Baker (1983-1986)
Number of episodes: 35
Average IMDB Rating: 6.8
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S21.E20 – “The Caves of Androzani” – IMDB Rating 8.9
- S22.E13 – “Revelation of the Daleks” – IMDB Rating 7.7
- S22.E3 – “Vengeance on Varos” – IMDB Rating 7.5
3 worst rated episodes:
- S21.E21 – “The Twin Dilemma” – IMDB Rating 5.3
- S22.E10 – “Timelash” – IMDB Rating 5.4
Colin Baker’s time as the Doctor was turbulent, coinciding with a period of instability for the show. His portrayal was bold, brash, and sometimes abrasive, a stark contrast to his predecessors. Although his era was initially met with criticism, it has gained retrospective appreciation. Key moments include his intense performance in “The Caves of Androzani” and his confrontations with classic foes like the Daleks. Despite the challenges, Baker’s Doctor is remembered for his colourful personality and the complexity he brought to the role.
11 – Paul McGann (1996 & 2013)
Number of episodes: 2 (1 TV movie, 1 mini-episode)
Average IMDB Rating: 7.0
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- Special Episode – “The Night of the Doctor” – 9.0 (mini-episode)
- TV Movie – “Doctor Who: The Movie” – IMDB Rating 6.3
Paul McGann’s portrayal of the Doctor was brief but impactful. He starred in a single TV movie and a mini-episode, yet left a lasting impression. His Doctor was romantic, eccentric, and compassionate, with a touch of Victorian elegance. Despite the limited screen time, his performance in “The Night of the Doctor” was highly praised, showcasing his depth and potential. McGann’s Doctor remains a fan favorite in audio dramas, where his character is further explored.
10 – Sylvester McCoy (1987-1989)
Number of episodes: 42
Average IMDB Rating: 6.9
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S25.E4 – “Remembrance of the Daleks” – IMDB Rating 8.5
- S26.E11 – “The Curse of Fenric” – IMDB Rating 8.2
- S26.E14 – “Survival” – IMDB Rating 7.5
3 worst rated episodes:
- S25.E6 – “The Happiness Patrol” – IMDB Rating 6.7
- S24.E11 – “Delta and the Bannermen” – IMDB Rating 5.7
- S24.E3 – “Time and the Rani” – IMDB Rating 5.3
Sylvester McCoy’s Doctor brought a darker, more mysterious edge to the character, which was a refreshing change. Despite facing cancellation, his era saw strong storylines and character development. McCoy’s portrayal was quirky, with a penchant for manipulation and a deeper, more enigmatic approach. Key moments include his strategic brilliance in “Remembrance of the Daleks” and his complex relationship with companion Ace. His Doctor is remembered for adding depth and intrigue to the series.
9 – Peter Davison (1981-1984)
Number of episodes: 69
Average IMDB Rating: 7.0
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S21.E20 – “The Caves of Androzani” – IMDB Rating 8.9
- S19.E22 – “Earthshock” – IMDB Rating 8.9
- S20.E23 – “The Five Doctors” – IMDB Rating 8.1
3 worst rated episodes:
- S19.E25 – “Time-Flight” – IMDB Rating 5.9
- S21.E3 – “Warriors of the Deep” – IMDB Rating 6.1
- S20.E1 – “Arc of Infinity” – IMDB Rating 6.1
Peter Davison’s Doctor was a significant departure from his predecessors, bringing a youthful vulnerability and compassion to the role. His era included standout episodes like “The Caves of Androzani,” where his heroic sacrifice became iconic. Davison’s Doctor was humble and empathetic, often finding himself in moral dilemmas. Memorable moments include the shocking death of companion Adric in “Earthshock” and his leadership in “The Five Doctors.” Despite some weaker episodes, Davison’s tenure is fondly remembered for its emotional depth.
8 – William Hartnell (1963-1984)
Number of episodes: 144
Average IMDB Rating: 7.5
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S2.E5 – “The Daleks” – IMDB Rating 8.3
- S4.E8 – “The Tenth Planet” – IMDB Rating 8.1
- S1.E1 – “An Unearthly Child” – IMDB Rating 8.0
3 worst rated episodes:
- S2.E16 – “The Web Planet” – IMDB Rating 5.9
- S3.E37 – “The Gunfighters” – IMDB Rating 6.1
- S1.E31 – “Strangers in Space” – IMDB Rating 6.3
As the first Doctor, William Hartnell set the foundation for the character with his stern and enigmatic portrayal. He brought an air of mystery and authority, which helped establish the show as a substantial hit. Hartnell’s Doctor was often gruff and authoritative but showed glimpses of warmth and vulnerability. Memorable moments include his initial encounter with the Daleks and his emotional farewell in “The Tenth Planet.” Despite the limitations of early TV production, Hartnell’s legacy endures.
7 – Patrick Troughton (1966-1985)
Number of episodes: 133
Average IMDB Rating: 7.6
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S6.E44 – “The War Games” – IMDB Rating 9.1
- S5.E1 – “The Tomb of the Cybermen” – IMDB Rating 8.2
- S6.E16 – “The Invasion” – IMDB Rating 8.1
3 worst rated episodes:
- S6.E3 – “The Dominators” – IMDB Rating 6.4
- S4.E19 – “The Underwater Menace” – IMDB Rating 6.1
- S6.E29 – “The Space Pirates” – IMDB Rating 5.2
Patrick Troughton’s Second Doctor was a bold and successful change, endearing him to fans and ensuring the show’s future. His portrayal blended humour with cunning, making him both endearing and unpredictable. Troughton’s Doctor was playful yet had a darker edge, often using his wits to outsmart enemies. Key moments include his battles with the Cybermen and the epic conclusion of “The War Games.” Troughton’s performance laid the groundwork for the character’s enduring appeal.
6 – Jon Pertwee (1970 – 1984)
Number of episodes: 128
Average IMDB Rating: 7.5
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S7.E21 – “Inferno” – IMDB Rating 8.4
- S10.E26 – “The Green Death” – IMDB Rating 8.2
- S8.E21 – “The Daemons” – IMDB Rating 7.8
3 worst rated episodes:
- S8.E17 – “Colony in Space” – IMDB Rating 6.8
- S9.E15 – “The Mutants” – IMDB Rating 6.6
- S9.E23 – “The Time Monster” – IMDB Rating 6.4
Jon Pertwee brought a touch of class and physicality to the Doctor, with a series of Earth-bound adventures emphasising action and intrigue. His era introduced iconic companions and adversaries, adding depth to the show’s mythology. Pertwee’s Doctor was dapper and action-oriented, often using gadgets and vehicles. Memorable moments include his dynamic with UNIT and his confrontations with the Master. Pertwee’s portrayal added a new dimension to the character, making him both a scientist and an action hero.
5 – Peter Capaldi (2008-2020)
Number of episodes: 44
Average IMDB Rating: 7.9
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S9.E11 – “Heaven Sent” – IMDB Rating 9.6
- S10.E11 – “World Enough and Time” – IMDB Rating 9.3
- S10.E12 – “The Doctor Falls” – IMDB Rating 9.2
3 worst rated episodes:
- S9.E9 – “Sleep No More” – IMDB Rating 6.0
- S8.E11 – “In the Forest of the Night” – IMDB Rating 6.3
- S8.E7 – “Kill the Moon” – IMDB Rating 6.5
Peter Capaldi’s Doctor combined grumpiness with a guitar-playing coolness, bringing a unique edge to the character. His profound monologues and alien aura added depth to the series. Capaldi’s Doctor was often intense and intimidating, with a sharp wit and a touch of melancholy. Memorable moments include his one-man show in “Heaven Sent” and his emotional farewell in “The Doctor Falls.” Capaldi’s portrayal was both complex and compelling, leaving a lasting impression on the series.
4 – Christopher Eccleston (2005-2020)
Number of episodes: 13
Average IMDB Rating: 8.1
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S1.E13 – “The Parting of the Ways” – IMDB Rating 9.0
- S1.E9 – “The Empty Child” – IMDB Rating 9.0
- S1.E6 – “Dalek” – IMDB Rating 8.6
3 worst rated episodes:
- S1.E11 – “Boom Town” – IMDB Rating 7.1
- S1.E7 – “The Long Game” – IMDB Rating 7.0
- S1.E4 – “Aliens of London” – IMDB Rating 6.9
Christopher Eccleston’s single season as the Doctor was pivotal for the 2005 revival. His energetic and intense portrayal brought a new audience to the show and revitalised the series. Eccleston’s Doctor was a manic ball of energy, with a mix of humour and deep emotional scars. Memorable moments include his battle with the Daleks in “Dalek” and his sacrificial regeneration in “The Parting of the Ways.” Despite his brief tenure, Eccleston’s impact on the series’ success is undeniable.
3 – Tom Baker (1974-1984)
Number of episodes: 172
Average IMDB Rating: 8.0
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S12.E11 – “Genesis of the Daleks” – IMDB Rating 9.0
- S14.E21 – “The Talons of Weng-Chiang” – IMDB Rating 8.6
- S17.E8 – “City of Death” – IMDB Rating 8.9
3 worst rated episodes:
- S17.E10 – “The Creature from the Pit” – IMDB Rating 6.7
- S15.E17 – “Underworld” – IMDB Rating 6.4
- S15.E8 – “The Invisible Enemy” – IMDB Rating 6.7
Tom Baker’s tenure as the Doctor is one of the most iconic in the show’s history. His unpredictable nature, humour, and iconic scarf left a lasting legacy. Baker’s Doctor was often eccentric and whimsical, yet capable of sudden seriousness. Memorable moments include his epic showdown in “Genesis of the Daleks” and his unexpected cameo in “The Day of the Doctor.” Baker’s portrayal continues to influence the character, making him one of the most beloved Doctors.
2 – Matt Smith (2010-2020)
Number of episodes: 44
Average IMDB Rating: 8.1
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- Special Episode – “The Day of the Doctor” – IMDB Rating 9.3
- S5.E1 – “The Eleventh Hour” – IMDB Rating 9.1
- S5.E10 – “Vincent and the Doctor” – IMDB Rating 8.9
3 worst rated episodes:
- S6.E3 – “The Curse of the Black Spot” – IMDB Rating 6.5
- S7.E13 – “Nightmare in Silver” – IMDB Rating 6.6
- S7.E0 – “The Doctor, the Widow and the Wardrobe” – IMDB Rating 6.7
Matt Smith’s Doctor brought a unique energy and quirkiness to the role, quickly winning over fans with his portrayal of an old soul in a young body. Smith’s Doctor was eccentric, with a love for bow ties and fish fingers with custard. Key moments include his debut in “The Eleventh Hour” and his touching interaction with Vincent van Gogh in “Vincent and the Doctor.” Smith’s ability to handle complex plots and his dynamic performance made his era memorable and impactful.
1 – David Tennant (2005-2023)
Number of episodes: 47
Average IMDB Rating: 8.5
Top 3 highest rated episodes:
- S3.E10 – “Blink” – IMDB Rating 9.8
- Special Episode – “The End of Time: Part Two” – IMDB Rating 9.4
- S4.E12 – “The Stolen Earth” – IMDB Rating 9.1
3 worst rated episodes:
- S2.E11 – “Fear Her” – IMDB Rating 6.0
- S2.E10 – “Love & Monsters” – IMDB Rating 6.1
- S4.E6 – “The Doctor’s Daughter” – IMDB Rating 6.6
David Tennant’s era is often regarded as the most successful in recent history. His charm, wit, and emotional depth captured the hearts of millions. Tennant’s Doctor was charismatic, with a balance of humour and intensity. Memorable moments include the chilling episode “Blink” and his tearful farewell in “The End of Time.” Tennant’s popularity is evidenced by his return for the 2023 Christmas specials, solidifying his status as one of the most beloved Doctors.
Final Thoughts
Ranking the Doctors is no easy task, as each brings something unique to the role. Our best Doctor Who, David Tennant currently holds the top spot, but every Doctor has contributed to the rich tapestry of Doctor Who. With Ncuti Gatwa stepping into the role, the future looks bright for this beloved series.
